You’ve decided to outsource your content writing. Good call. Now you need to figure out who to hand it to.

On one side, agencies sending you polished proposals. On the other, freelance profiles you found on LinkedIn or on platforms like Upwork. And in the middle, a question that comes up a lot: should you work with a freelance SEO copywriter or with an agency?

I’m a freelance SEO/GEO copywriter myself, and I also work with agencies as part of their teams. So I know both sides. And honestly, the right answer isn’t the same for every small business.

What a provider does before they start writing matters more than whether they’re a freelancer or an agency. Here’s how to compare the two, and above all, the questions to ask before you sign anything.

My honest answer: an agency is the better fit if you need high volume and a wide range of skills. A freelance copywriter makes more sense if the quality of your voice matters more than quantity and you want to talk directly to the person writing. Either way, what makes the difference is how well they understand your business.

Freelancer or agency: what actually changes for a small business

On paper, both deliver content optimized for Google and, more and more, for AI answers. In practice, the way they work is very different.

With an agency, you work with a team. A project manager sits between you and the writers, sometimes alongside an SEO consultant or a designer. You get more capacity, but you don’t always talk directly to the person writing your content.

With a freelancer, it’s the opposite. You have one point of contact who learns your business, picks the angles and writes. Communication is more direct, but their capacity is naturally more limited.

Here are the main differences at a glance:

CriteriaFreelance copywriterAgency
Point of contactThe person who writes, directlyA project manager, between you and the writers
VolumeMore limited, ideal for a steady but moderate paceHigh, several pieces a week possible
ExpertiseOften specialized in one type of content or industryBroader: content, technical SEO, ads
ContinuityDepends on one personA team can step in
BudgetMostly thinking and writing timeAlso covers coordination and overhead
Best forSpecialized expertise, a voice to preserveHigh volume, varied needs

This table shows general trends, not hard rules. Some agencies stay very close to their clients, and some freelancers team up to handle more volume. That’s exactly why it’s worth looking at how each provider works rather than at their label.

When an agency is the better choice

Agencies have real advantages, and it would be dishonest to skip over them.

First, volume. If you need to publish several pieces a week, rewrite every page of your website or produce content in several languages at once, a team can keep up with that pace more easily than one person.

Second, a broader skill set. If your site also needs a technical audit, link building or paid campaigns, an agency can handle everything in one place. For a small business without a marketing team, having a single provider for all of that is easier to manage.

Third, continuity. If a writer goes on vacation or leaves the agency, someone else picks up the work. You’re not relying on one person.

When a freelance SEO copywriter is a better fit

A freelancer becomes the stronger option when the quality of your message matters more than volume.

That’s often the case for businesses with specialized expertise, or for business owners who want their content to genuinely sound like them. To write well about what you do, someone needs to understand your field, your clients and the way you talk. That’s easier when the person asking the questions is also the one doing the writing.

A client who reached out to me after a disappointing experience with an agency summed it up simply: whenever he had a question or a change to make, it took forever, because everything had to go through a team and several departments. He also felt those departments didn’t really work together. And what disappointed him most were the SEO results he’d been promised that never materialized.

Not every agency works that way, thankfully. But responsiveness and promises are exactly the two things to check before you sign.

A freelancer also makes sense when you have a specific need: setting up an editorial strategy, a few in-depth articles a month, rewriting your service pages. You pay for what you need, without the overhead.

On the flip side, check their availability, their turnaround times and what happens if they’re away. A good freelancer will have a clear answer.

Why not both?

It’s an option people often forget: the two aren’t mutually exclusive.

More and more agencies bring in specialized freelance writers for certain clients or topics. The freelancer becomes part of the team, sometimes under the agency’s brand, and the agency keeps the coordination. That’s actually part of what I do.

Having seen it from the inside, a white-label collaboration works well when four things are in place. The agency gives me a real brief on the client, with access to the information, and to the client themselves if needed. We agree from the start on who approves what, and by when. I can ask my questions directly, without going through three people. And above all, the agency respects my work: feedback with reasons, not a full rewrite without talking to me. When that’s in place, the end client doesn’t see any difference, except in the quality of the content.

For a small business, it can also mean working with an agency for technical SEO and ads, and with a freelance copywriter for in-depth content. What matters is that everyone knows who’s doing what, and that your content stays consistent.

A quick test I ran on November 9, 2026: on Google, the search “SEO and GEO copywriter Canada” showed an AI Overview, and the top results were Upwork, LinkedIn profiles and job boards. Perplexity pulled 9 of its 10 sources from LinkedIn. So check your future provider’s LinkedIn profile too, not just their website.

Questions to ask an SEO copywriter before you sign

This is where it all comes down. Whether you’re talking to an agency or a freelancer, these questions will quickly tell you if you’re in good hands.

How will you get to know my business?

A good provider starts by asking questions: about your clients, your offers, what sets you apart and what you expect from your content. If they hand you a list of topics before they even know what you sell, be careful.

And honestly, if there’s one question small businesses forget most often, it’s this one: “How will you capture my expertise?” A kickoff interview? Regular check-ins? That’s what makes the difference between generic content and content that shows what you actually know. I go into more detail in my article on how to turn your expertise into content that attracts clients.

Who will actually write my content?

With an agency, ask who your writer will be, whether it’ll be the same person over time and whether you can talk to them. With a freelancer, ask whether they subcontract any of the work.

There’s no wrong answer as such. But you have a right to know.

How do you use AI?

These days, almost everyone uses AI at some point in the process. The real question is where and how.

A provider who uses it for research, analysis or structure, then writes and fact-checks everything themselves, isn’t doing the same job as one who publishes AI-generated text almost as is. Ask directly. A vague answer tells you a lot.

How do you choose topics?

Good topics don’t come out of thin air. They come from your prospects’ questions, your Search Console data when you have some, real searches and what AI tools are saying about your industry.

Ask how they build their editorial calendar and what they do when an article doesn’t perform.

What do you promise on GEO?

This is probably the most revealing question right now.

Nobody can guarantee you’ll be cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google’s AI Overviews. These tools pick their sources in ways that aren’t fully public, and their answers change from one search to the next. A serious provider will talk about best practices, tracking and testing. Not guarantees. If you want to understand what can realistically be done, I explain how to be visible on Google and in ChatGPT answers.

How will we measure results?

Rankings, impressions, visits, contact requests: agree from the start on what you’ll track and how often. And keep in mind that SEO takes time. Anyone promising results within a few weeks is selling you a dream.

Who owns the content and the accounts?

It sounds obvious, but get it in writing. The content you pay for should belong to you, and your accounts (website, Search Console, Analytics) should stay in your name, even if you stop working together.

Your pre-signing checklist

Tick off each question as you meet providers. You can also print it.

0/8 questions asked
Want to ask someone these questions right now? I'll be completely transparent about how I work, and I'll also tell you if an agency would be a better fit for your situation. Book a 30-minute call

Red flags to watch for

Some signs should set off alarm bells, whoever the provider is.

A guaranteed ranking on Google or a guaranteed citation in ChatGPT. Nobody controls the algorithms. Anyone promising the top spot isn’t telling you the truth.

A very low price per word for a large volume. Writing good content takes research, thinking and editing. Below a certain price, that time simply isn’t there. And length isn’t everything either: I cover this in my article on the ideal length for SEO content.

No questions about your business. If nobody asks about your clients or your goals, the content will inevitably be generic.

Content “optimized for ChatGPT” with no explanation. GEO relies mostly on SEO fundamentals and on clear, reliable content. If you want a refresher on the differences, read my article on SEO vs GEO.

The right provider is the one who understands your business

Freelancer or agency, what really matters is how the provider will get to know your business, choose your topics and write content that sounds like you.

If you need volume and a range of skills, an agency will often be the better fit. If you’re looking for a precise voice and a direct point of contact, a freelancer has real strengths. And in some cases, the two can work together very well.

Take the time to ask the right questions before you sign. The answers will tell you more than any sales proposal.

Take action

Looking for someone to write your SEO/GEO content who starts by understanding your business? I help with SEO/GEO strategy and writing: we start from your goals and your clients, then I write content built for Google, for AI tools and, above all, for the people who'll read it. Let's talk about your project